{
  "project": "Qalib",
  "author": "Milad Shaddelan",
  "review_date": "2026-10-31",
  "status": "Engineering prototype; development paused",
  "scope": "Retrospective selected-component tests and replay of stored evidence. No live model evaluation or production benchmark.",
  "component_tests": {
    "tests": 41,
    "failures": 0,
    "errors": 0,
    "skipped": 0,
    "test_groups": [
      "tests.pipeline.test_cut3b_step_a",
      "tests.pipeline.test_deterministic_verdict",
      "tests.test_skip_discipline_f089.TestAggregatorSkipDoesNotContributeToPassed",
      "tests.test_skip_discipline_f089.TestLintSupervisorNoPythonFilesIsSKIPNotPASS",
      "tests.test_skip_discipline_f089.TestQualitySupervisorRunEslintNoFrontendFilesIsSKIPNotPASS",
      "tests.test_skip_discipline_f089.TestQualitySupervisorRunLintNoPythonFilesIsSKIPNotPASS",
      "tests.test_verdict_promotion_semantics"
    ]
  },
  "replays": [
    {
      "fixture_id": "4497",
      "selected_scope": {
        "required_criteria": 4,
        "matcher_aggregate": "PASS"
      },
      "provenance_scope": {
        "required_criteria": 9,
        "matcher_aggregate": "INCONCLUSIVE"
      },
      "required_criterion_verdicts": [
        "PASS",
        "PASS",
        "PASS",
        "INCONCLUSIVE",
        "INCONCLUSIVE",
        "PASS",
        "INCONCLUSIVE",
        "INCONCLUSIVE",
        "INCONCLUSIVE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "fixture_id": "3839",
      "selected_scope": {
        "required_criteria": 7,
        "matcher_aggregate": "INCONCLUSIVE"
      },
      "provenance_scope": {
        "required_criteria": 10,
        "matcher_aggregate": "INCONCLUSIVE"
      },
      "required_criterion_verdicts": [
        "INCONCLUSIVE",
        "INCONCLUSIVE",
        "INCONCLUSIVE",
        "PASS",
        "INCONCLUSIVE",
        "INCONCLUSIVE",
        "PASS",
        "PASS",
        "INCONCLUSIVE",
        "INCONCLUSIVE"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "interpretation": "PASS is the deterministic matcher output, not an independently established correctness label. Saved evidence may not establish every clause of a compound requirement. The audit identified matcher and repair edge cases.",
  "unmeasured": [
    "Model accuracy",
    "Comparative benchmark performance",
    "Production reliability"
  ],
  "implementation_snapshot": {
    "qalib_local_head": "006065a58e6ace56b6e3576e9be6a46914e1444d",
    "fartower_local_head": "439d9e18817b30e4d63e3c137a5575b87dc149fc",
    "note": "Inspected local Qalib worktree also contained uncommitted changes; commit IDs identify the local history, not a complete hash of the evaluated working tree. The June 10 SQL extension is local history beyond the checked remote default branches."
  }
}